| Year | Country | Title Holder |
| 1951 | Sweden | Kiki Hakansson |
| 1952 | Sweden | May Louise Flodin |
| 1953 | France | Denise Perrier |
| 1954 | Egypt | Antigone Costanda |
| 1955 | Venezuela | Susana Duijm |
| 1956 | West Germany | Petra Schürmann |
| 1957 | Finland | Marita Lindahl |
| 1958 | South Africa | Penelope Anne Coelen |
| 1959 | Netherlands(Holland) | Corine Rottschafer |
| 1960 | Argentina | Norma Cappagli |
| 1961 | United Kingdom | Rosemarie Frankland |
| 1962 | Netherlands(Holland) | Catharina Lodders |
| 1963 | Jamaica | Carole Crawford |
| 1964 | United Kingdom | Ann Sydney |
| 1965 | United Kingdom | Lesley Langley |
| 1966 | India | Reita Faria |
| 1967 | Peru | Madeleine Hartog Bell |
| 1968 | Australia | Penelope Plummer |
| 1969 | Austria | Eva Rueber-Staier |
| 1970 | Grenada | Jennifer Hosten |
| 1971 | Brazil | Lucia Petterle |
| 1972 | Australia | Belinda Green |
| 1973 | United States | Marjorie Wallace |
| 1974 | United Kingdom | Helen Morgan |
| 1974 | South Africa | Anneline Kriel |
| 1975 | Puerto Rico | Wilnelia Merced |
| 1976 | Jamaica | Cindy Breakspeare |
| 1977 | Sweden | Mary Stavin |
| 1978 | Argentina | Silvana Suarez |
| 1979 | Bermuda | Gina Swainson |
| 1980 | West Germany | Gabriella Brum |
| 1980 | Guam | Kimberley Santos |
| 1981 | Venezuela | Pilín Leon |
| 1982 | Dominican Republic | Mariasela Alvarez Lebron |
| 1983 | United Kingdom | Sarah-Jane Hutt |
| 1984 | Venezuela | Astrid Carolina Herrera |
| 1985 | Iceland | Hofi Karlsdottir |
| 1986 | Trinidad and Tobago | Giselle Laronde |
| 1987 | Austria | Ulla Weigerstorfer |
| 1988 | Iceland | Linda Petursdottir |
| 1989 | Poland | Aneta Kreglicka |
| 1990 | United States | Gina Tolleson |
| 1991 | Venezuela | Ninibeth Leal |
| 1992 | Russia | Julia Kourotchkina |
| 1993 | Jamaica | Lisa Hanna |
| 1994 | India | Aishwarya Rai |
| 1995 | Venezuela | Jacqueline Aguilera |
| 1996 | Greece | Irene Skliva |
| 1997 | India | Diana Hayden |
| 1998 | Israel | Linor Abargil |
| 1999 | India | Yukta Mookhey |
| 2000 | India | Priyanka Chopra |
| 2001 | Nigeria | Agbani Darego |
| 2002 | Turkey | Azra Akin |
| 2003 | Ireland | Rosanna Davison |
| 2004 | Peru | Maria Julia Mantilla |
| 2005 | Iceland | Unnur Birna Vilhjalmsdottir |
| 2006 | Czech Republic | Tatana Kucharova |
| 2007 | China | Zhang Zilin |
| 2008 | Russia | Ksenia Sukhinova |
| 2009 | Gibraltar | Kaiane Aldorino |